A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis conducted by Peng Xie et al. investigated the comparative efficacy and tolerability of adjunctive atypical antipsychotics for treatment-resistant depression. This post will summarize the clinical findings of this study.
ATYPICAL ANTIPSYCHOTICS INCLUDED:
18 randomized controlled trials were included with following seven different types (and dosages) of atypical antipsychotic agents:
- standard-dose aripiprazole (n = 746)
- low-dose aripiprazole (n = 253)
- standard-dose olanzapine/fluoxetine (OFC, n = 599)
- low-dose OFC (n = 59)
- quetiapine (mean 250–350mg daily, n = 345)
- quetiapine (mean 150–250mg daily, n = 344)
- standard-dose risperidone (n = 217)
Note: low dose was defined as less than half the defined dose by the FDA-approved indications.
All standard-dose agents were significantly more effective compared with placebo, EXCEPT FOR low-dose OFC and low-dose aripiprazole.
(* LOW DOSES ANTIPSYCHOTICS NOT FOUND EFFICACIOUS).
(1) All standard-dose agents had significantly more side-effect discontinuations than placebo, EXCEPT FOR risperidone.
(2) Quetiapine (mean dose 250–350 mg daily) and standard-dose OFC had significantly more side-effect discontinuations than low-dose OFC.
(3) Only quetiapine (mean dose 250–350mg daily) had a significantly higher rate of all-cause discontinuation than placebo.
(MEDICATION OF CHOICE IN THIS CLASS: RISPERIDONE).
QUALITY OF LIFE:
(1) In terms of the Quality of life/functioning outcome: only standard-dose risperidone and standard-dose aripiprazole were significantly more beneficial than placebo.
(2) Standard-dose risperidone was significantly more beneficial than quetiapine.
(MEDICATION OF CHOICE IN THIS CLASS: STANDARD DOSE RISPERIDONE & STANDARD DOSE ARIPIPRAZOLE)
According to this Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis: standard-dose risperidone appeared to be the most beneficial in balancing efficacy, tolerability, and quality of life.
- Int J Neuropsychopharmacol. 2015 Oct; 18(11): pyv060.
Please do post your questions or comments below.
Dr. Harvinder Singh, M.D. (Admin)
Enroll in our online course to have access to all important clinically relevant psychiatry topics in one place.